Summary
This lesson guides students to understand how reading strategies enhance comprehension of a text. Students read a variety of texts, including artwork, a video, and a short story, using the OPTIC strategy. Students use the strategy to make Observations and Predictions about the text to aid their understanding of Themes and Inferences that will then allow them to draw Conclusions. Students then access prior knowledge and identify pieces of evidence that contribute to their understanding of texts. At the end of the lesson, students evaluate their use of reading strategies and discuss how their use of the OPTIC strategy increased their comprehension of visual and written texts.
Essential Question(s)
How can using reading strategies enhance one’s comprehension?
Snapshot
Engage
Students engage with their prior knowledge of visual literacy and “read” an image.
Explore
Students explore art as a non-print text and use reading strategies to enhance their comprehension.
Explain
Students summarize their understanding of an image and explain how reading strategies aid in comprehension.
Extend
Students apply the OPTIC reading strategy to other texts, including a video and a short story, to demonstrate how the strategy enhances comprehension.
Evaluate
Students evaluate their use of reading strategies and reflect on how the strategies increased their comprehension.
Materials
Lesson Slides (attached)
OPTIC Recipe Card handout (attached; print two-sided, in color; one per student)
OPTIC Recipe Card Template handout (attached; one per student)
OPTIC Recipe Card Key document (attached; optional)
“The Bully” short story (linked; one per 1–2 students)
Sticky notes (two different colors; one of each color per student)
Notebook paper (one sheet per student)
Highlighters (three different colors per student)
Tape (one piece per student)
Music (one song for the Mingle instructional strategy)
Preparation
This 5E lesson is designed to be delivered across three class periods, but many of the sections provide enough content to take up a whole class session. The teacher may choose to divide the lesson up between multiple class sessions, especially if students need more time to comprehend the material and strategies involved.
The Extend section of this lesson continues with the theme of bullying. This portion of the lesson has students engage with both the video and text versions of “The Bully” by Roger Dean Kiser. However, you may choose a different video and text source for the Extend activity. If you do choose to use “The Bully,” you must download and print copies of the short story using the link provided above.
Engage
15 Minute(s)
Use the attached Lesson Slides to guide the lesson. Begin the lesson with a Think-Pair-Share activity to access prior knowledge. Go to slide 3 and pass out one sticky note and one piece of paper to each student. Have each student individually consider a definition for “visual literacy” and write their definition on their sticky note. Have them write on their piece of paper a list of at least three reading strategies that they currently use to help them comprehend a text.
Pair each student with a partner and have them share their answers. Ensure that they keep their lists for later in the lesson.
Display slide 4. Explain that visual literacy communications with visual images as well as, or instead of, words. Inform students that processes and reading analysis tools can improve understanding and expand literacy in general. Explain that this helps strengthen skills that improve comprehension.
Present slide 5 and the essential question, “How can using reading strategies enhance one’s comprehension?”
Show slide 6 and introduce the lesson objectives.
Display slide 7. Tell students that they are going to read a piece of art during this activity. Communicate to students that this task requires visual literacy. Describe visual literacy as a set of reading skills and strategies that help people “decode, interpret, create, question, challenge, and evaluate texts” (Carry, n.d.). Distribute one copy of the OPTIC Recipe Card handout to each student.
Display slide 8 and introduce students to the image. Have students fill in the “Initial Comprehension” section of their OPTIC Recipe Cards with one or two sentences that describe their understanding of the image.
Tell students that using a process and reading analysis tools aids comprehension and expands visual and multimodal literacies. Reading text and “reading” art both strengthen skills that aid in all aspects of reading across different media and for different purposes.
Explore
30 Minute(s)
Display slide 9 and introduce the It’s OPTIC-al instructional strategy. Tell students that this strategy helps students make observations (O) and predictions (P), identify titles and themes (T), cite evidence used for inferences (I) and draw conclusions (C). Tell students that they will, as a class, use this strategy to analyze the image they previously examined, The Shiner. Use the attached OPTIC Recipe Card Key document for guidance, if needed.
Display slide 10 and introduce a modified version of the Photo or Picture Deconstruction strategy. Under the “Observations” heading on their handouts, have students independently create a list of ten key, concrete observations that are most important to the understanding of the visual text. These observations would be key details that students would underline or highlight if the visual text were instead print text. In this setting, these concrete observations should be visual details only.
Invite students to each share out one detail. As they share, record their responses on the board.
Display slide 11. Ask students to make three predictions about what is happening in the art under the “Predictions” section of their handouts. Distribute three differently colored highlighters to each student. Have them highlight each prediction with a different color.
Show slide 12. Have students brainstorm potential titles for the art on their handouts under the “Titles” section. Invite students to share out their ideas. As students share, discuss how their titles give important information about the main ideas, or themes, present in the art.
Click on the slide to display the official title of the work, The Shiner, and discuss how the title focuses on the main idea and main detail of the artwork. Identify the artist and the time period of the work, which are two pieces of information that are also important to reading. Ask students to identify details in The Shiner that provide information about the artist, title, and time period of the work.
Move to slide 13. Have students turn their predictions into inferences by assigning evidence from their observations list to each prediction. Have them underline or highlight supporting evidence using the color-coding system from the prediction step of the lesson. Have them mark each piece of evidence in the same color as the prediction that piece of evidence supports. Discuss any important prior knowledge students possess that aids comprehension.
Display slide 14 and introduce the final part of the OPTIC strategy: Conclusions. Explain that drawing conclusions involves identifying who is pictured, what has happened, and where, when, why, and how it took place.
Display slide 15 and introduce the Pass the Problem instructional strategy. Tell students that they should pass their handouts around the room and fill in the one of the six blanks underneath the “Conclusion” heading each time they receive a new handout. Have them write one of their conclusions about who, what, when, where, why, or how next to the corresponding word. Explain that after they write one conclusion they must pass their handout to the right (or the direction of your choice) each time they hear the word “pass.” Ensure that students write their names on their papers before you have them begin passing.
Show slide 16 and have students pass their recipe cards to the right. Have them respond to the “Who” blank on the handout they receive. Allow one or two minutes for students to record their responses. Have students pass their recipe cards to the right and respond to the “What” blank on their handouts. Repeat this process until each student’s card has six different answers for each category, then have them return their cards to the original owners.
Explain
35 Minute(s)
Explain to students that they should now use their OPTIC Recipe Card handout to create a story about the painting.
Display slide 17. Have students review the art and their OPTIC Recipe Card handouts. Explain that students should now create a narrative paragraph describing the painting that consists of five to six sentences, one sentence for each of the categories under the “Conclusion” section of their handouts. Have them describe the picture’s context, setting, characters, and plot or conflict, and support their conclusions using evidence from the text to support their descriptions.
Encourage students to use the responses from their recipe cards to describe the context of their stories. Have them use specific details, imagery, and evidence from the art to support their inferences and conclusions. If necessary, read the below sample narrative to the class.
Have students write their stories under the “Final Comprehension” section of their recipe card handouts. Provide additional paper if needed.
Display slide 18 and introduce the Mingle instructional strategy. Have students help each other tape their stories to their backs. Play music and have them stand up and mingle, then stop the music and have them gather in groups of three or four. Have each student read the story taped to the back of the person next to them in the circle, then have them turn and read the story of the person on their other side.
Have groups then select a volunteer to read one group member’s story to the whole class. While each volunteer reads, have the other students close their eyes and visualize the images presented in the narrative.
Display slide 19 and have students review their initial comprehension of the painting then respond to the final question on their handouts under the “Evaluate” heading. Have them compare and contrast their initial comprehension, before using OPTIC, to their final comprehension, after using OPTIC, as they respond. Call on students to share how the reading strategies enhanced their comprehension.
Display slide 20 and have each student discuss the differences between their initial and final comprehension with a partner.
Invite volunteers to share some of these differences with the whole class. Lead a class discussion about how students’ initial observations from the beginning of the lesson were vague when compared to their observations from the end of the lesson after using OPTIC. Explain that the OPTIC strategy helped students identify main ideas, make predictions, identify themes, make inferences, and draw conclusions, which created a more detailed, narrative description of the art. Explain to students that a reading process, like OPTIC, enhances comprehension.
Extend
50 Minute(s)
Explain to the class that using a reading process to analyze art is similar to using a reading process to analyze a print text. Tell students that the OPTIC strategy helped students make observations, extend predictions, identify main ideas and themes in a title, cite evidence to create inferences, and draw conclusions, which are all things good readers do to aid their comprehension.
Move to slide 21 and distribute one copy of the attached OPTIC Recipe Card Template handout to each student. Have students apply the OPTIC strategy to a video “text” in a Think-Pair-Share activity.
Tell students that they should fill in their OPTIC Recipe Card Templates as they watch the video, The Bully. Explain that by applying the OPTIC strategy to the video, they practicing visual literacy in a different context using the same strategies.
Display slide 22 and play the video. Remind students to record important details on their handouts as they watch the video.
Pause the video at minute marker 2:30 and have students make predictions about the characters Roger Kaiser and Tony Claxton, what the theme of the video may be based on the title, and what evidence or prior knowledge they will need to make inferences.
Continue to play the video and have students complete the remainder of their OPTIC Recipe Card Templates. Once the video is over, have them share their responses with an Elbow Partner.
Display slide 23 and distribute one copy of “The Bully” short story and three different colors of highlighters to each student. Read the story aloud and have students follow along. As they follow along, have them apply the OPTIC reading strategy and annotate the printed text by underlining key details, making predictions, assessing the title and theme, citing evidence for inferences, and drawing conclusions about the passage. Have them also label the elements of who, what, where, when, why, and how as they appear in the text.
Show slide 24 and have students write a one-paragraph, descriptive summary of “The Bully,” using the who, what, when, where, why, and how elements they identified.
Evaluate
20 Minute(s)
Display slide 25 and introduce students to the I Used To Think... But Now I Know instructional strategy. Return students’ sticky notes from the Engage and have them review what they wrote. Have a few students share what they wrote on their sticky notes and have all students post their sticky notes on the “I Used to Think” column of the T-Chart.
Give each student another sticky note in a different color. On this sticky note, have students write whether or not the OPTIC reading reading strategies aided their comprehension and have them explain why and how. Have students post this sticky note under the “But Now I Know” side of the chart. Choose a few sticky notes to read aloud to the class.
Display slide 26. Discuss with students how the OPTIC process differed across the tasks of analyzing the illustration, video, and short story even though it was the same strategy. Explain to students that their “But Now I Know” responses affirm that using reading strategies enhances comprehension. Help students connect the process they used to improve their visual literacy to the similar process they used to improve their comprehension of the text. Encourage them to continue to use these reading skills and strategies to decode, interpret, creation, question, challenge, and evaluate texts across media.
Resources
ANAMALoff. (2009, August 25). “The bully” [Video]. YouTube. https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=LhHIY1CnO-o
Carry, D. (n.d.). Visual literacy: Using images to increase comprehension [PowerPoint Slides]. Reading Recovery. https://readingrecovery.org/images/pdfs/Conferences/NC09/Handouts/Carry_Visual_Literacy.pdf
K20 Center. (n.d.). I used to think . . . but now I know. Strategies. https://learn.k20center.ou.edu/strategy/137
K20 Center. (n.d.). Elbow partners. Strategies. https://learn.k20center.ou.edu/strategy/116
K20 Center. (n.d.). T-chart. Strategies. https://learn.k20center.ou.edu/strategy/86
K20 Center. (n.d.). It’s OPTIC-al. Strategies. https://learn.k20center.ou.edu/strategy/99
K20 Center. (n.d.). Mingle. Strategies. https://learn.k20center.ou.edu/strategy/53
K20 Center. (n.d.). Pass the problem. Strategies. https://learn.k20center.ou.edu/strategy/151
K20 Center. (n.d.). Photo or picture deconstruction. Strategies. https://learn.k20center.ou.edu/strategy/140
K20 Center. (n.d.). Think-pair-share. Strategies. https://learn.k20center.ou.edu/strategy/139
Kiser, R. D. (n.d.). The bully. East of the Web. https://www.eastoftheweb.com/short-stories/UBooks/Bull.shtml
Rockwell, N. (1953). The young lady with the shiner [Painting]. The Saturday Evening Post. https://www.saturdayeveningpost.com/2009/08/school-daze/cover_9530523/