Authentic Lessons for 21st Century Learning

Nursing Then and Now: Memoirs of Alcott and Whitman

Compare & Contrast Nursing Past and Present

Polly Base, Daniel Schwarz, Bethany Farley | Published: April 25th, 2024 by K20 Center

  • Grade Level Grade Level 10th, 11th, 12th
  • Subject Subject English/Language Arts, Nursing
  • Course Course A.P. Literature and Composition, American Literature
  • Time Frame Time Frame 150-200 minutes
  • Duration More 3-4 class periods

Summary

In this lesson, students look through the lens of nursing to think about what it means to overcome adversity. Students will read Civil War-era memoirs from Walt Whitman and Louisa May Alcott. They will then compare and contrast the descriptions of nursing in those texts with an account of modern nursing as told from the perspective of a practicing nurse. Using a hands-on activity, students will experience nursing triage and then reflect on what they have learned—both about themselves and the profession of nursing.

Essential Question(s)

How do we, as humans, overcome adversity? How has the field of nursing changed from the Civil War to the present?

Snapshot

Engage

Students create their own definitions of “resilience” and “adversity,” including examples, and engage in a Think, Pair, Share activity with a partner and with the whole class.

Explore

Students devise questions about nursing for the ICAP professional using Padlet, and they read and analyze the Alcott and Whitman historical memoirs about nursing.

Explain

Students interview a nurse using the Padlet questions they developed.

Extend

Students collaborate as they experience a triage activity led by the school nurse and answer one of the essential questions by writing an informative One-Pager using the Senses of War chart, the excerpts, and their experience during the nurse interview and triage activity.

Evaluate

Students reflect on the lesson using the Mirror, Microscope, Binoculars questions.

Materials

  • Devices with Internet access

  • Lesson Slides (attached)

  • Hospital Sketches excerpt (attached; one per student)

  • Specimen Days excerpt (optional; attached; one per student)

  • “The Wound-Dresser” (optional; attached; one per student)

  • One-Pager Rubric (attached; one per student)

  • Sticky notes for students (purple, yellow, and blue recommended)

  • Highlighters for students

  • Poster board

  • Pens or pencils

  • Notebook paper

  • Chart paper

  • Triage Activity Instructions (two copies, for the teacher and the nurse)

  • Gauze (optional)

  • Rubber gloves (optional)

  • Stethoscopes (optional)

  • Medical tape (optional)

  • Penlights (optional)

  • Automated blood pressure cuff (optional)

  • Eye chart (optional)

  • Band-Aids (optional)

  • Medical tape (optional)

  • Telfa dressings (optional)

  • ABD gauze pads (optional)

  • Fabric sling (optional)

  • Alcohol swabs (optional)

Engage

15 Minute(s)

Introduce the lesson by displaying the title on slide 2 in the attached Lesson Slides.

Display slides 3-4. Take a couple of minutes to review the essential questions and the learning objectives with your students.

Display slide 5. Share the Think, Pair, Share strategy with the students. Instruct the students to take out a piece of notebook paper and write their own definitions of “resilience” and “adversity.” 

Pair the students to share their answers and devise a common definition. Ask pairs to share their answers with the class.

Explore

60 Minute(s)

Display slide 6. Have students go to the ICAP Nursing Questions Padlet using the QR code or Bitly on the slide. Instruct students to write at least two questions they would like to ask a nurse. Remind the students to ask higher-order thinking questions by creating open-ended questions. 

Display slide 7. Distribute copies of the Specimen Days Excerpt and Hospital Sketches Excerpt, along with highlighters. As you are reading the first text aloud to the students, as a class, complete a Looks Like, Sounds Like, Feels Like chart entitled “Senses of War.” Repeat these actions with the second text on the same chart. 

Display slide 8. Direct students to read the text on their own using the Why-Lighting strategy. Students should highlight the parts of the text that remind them of “adversity” and “resilience.” Remind students to include why they highlighted passages in the margin of the paper.

Display slide 9. Return to the Padlet, and instruct the students to write one or two more questions they would ask a nurse after reading the two texts.

Explain

20 Minute(s)

Display slide 10. Welcome and introduce the visiting nurse. Ask students to introduce themselves to the nurse. Share the ICAP Nursing Questions Padlet with the students. Call on each student to read one question for the visiting nurse. Continue to let students ask questions for half of the class period.

Extend

60 Minute(s)

Display slide 11. Ask the nurse to give directions for the triage activity. 

Display slides 12–13. Direct the students to complete a One-Pager on a piece of notebook paper, answering one of the essential questions by reflecting on what they have learned about nursing over the past few class periods. Students should reflect upon the following as they are writing:

  • Senses of War chart

  • Why-Lighted articles

  • Their experience during the interview and triage activity

Provide the students with the One-Pager Rubric to guide their writing expectations.

Evaluate

15 Minute(s)

Display slide 14. On pieces of notebook paper, have your students complete the Mirror, Microscope, Binoculars strategy by reflecting on what they have learned about nursing over the past few class periods. Ask students to reflect on the following prompt: 

  • Mirror: How has your thinking changed about the adversity and resilience of nursing professionals over time?

  • Microscope: Now I can see that nursing…

  • Binoculars: How is nursing impacted by what is going on in society? What could be done to change the field of nursing?

Collect both the Mirror, Microscope, Binoculars responses and the One-Pagers, and use them to assess student learning.

Resources