Authentic Lessons for 21st Century Learning

Woody Guthrie: A Better World A'Comin'

Contributions of Influential Oklahomans

Sarah Brewer, Bj Sneed | Published: November 22nd, 2022 by K20 Center

  • Grade Level Grade Level 9th, 10th, 11th, 12th
  • Subject Subject Social Studies
  • Course Course Oklahoma History
  • Time Frame Time Frame 100 - 150 minutes
  • Duration More 2 -3 class periods

Summary

What motivated and inspired legendary folk musician, Woody Guthrie, to create and perform music? Students will explore this question throughout this lesson by participating in a gallery walk analysis of Guthrie photos and quotes and then using his lyrics to determine the political and social issues that Guthrie highlighted with his music. To extend their learning, students will consider how Guthrie's most popular song, This Land Is Your Land, has been reinterpreted over time.

Essential Question(s)

What purposes can music have? How can music inspire change?

Snapshot

Engage - Students consider the purposes music can have and the reasons why people create and perform music.

Explore - Students analyze photos and quotes to make inferences about why Woody Guthrie created and performed music.

Explain - Students analyze Woody Guthrie’s song lyrics to determine some of the political and social issues he highlighted with his music.

Extend - Students determine how Woody Guthrie’s song This Land Is Your Land has been reinterpreted and adapted overtime.

Evaluate - Students use Woody Guthrie’s lyrics to create a blackout poem that reflects Guthrie’s political and social commentary.

Materials

  • Lesson slides

  • internet capable devices

  • Woody Guthrie Gallery Walk Posters (1 set, printed and hung around the room)

  • Music Analysis Handout (1 per student)

  • Music Analysis Handout with Teacher’s Notes

  • Woody Guthrie Song Handout (1 song per group with copies for each student)

  • Highlighters (optional)

  • Headphones (1 per student, optional)

  • Woody Guthrie Song List with Teacher’s Notes

  • This Land Is Your Land Handout (1 per student)

  • Blackout Poetry Examples

Engage

Divide students into small groups of 3-4.

Display slide 3 and, using the Think-Pair-Share strategy, ask students to consider the two questions on the slide:

  • What purposes can music have?

  • Why do people create and perform music?

Give students one minute to individually think about these questions. After one minute is up, invite students to share their thoughts with their small groups. Then, call on someone at each group to share their responses with the whole class.

Display slide 4. Share with students that throughout this lesson they should consider the following essential questions - What purposes can music have? and how can music inspire change? as they explore the musical work of one of America’s most influential folk musicians, Woody Guthrie. Consider also sharing the lesson objectives on slide 5.

Explore

Display slide 6. Tell students that Woody Guthrie was born in Okemah, Oklahoma in 1912, learning music throughout his childhood from family and friends. He grew up as the Great Depression, coupled with the Dust Bowl, devastated Oklahoma, Texas and the surrounding region. By the time Guthrie was a teenager he had moved to Texas and from there joined the thousands of people fleeing the dustbowl and migrated to California looking for work. This experience profoundly influenced Guthrie’s early music.

Tell students that to begin their exploration of Guthrie and his music they are going to participate in a Gallery Walk. Display slide 7 and distribute copies of the Music Analysis Handout to each student. Explain that there are five gallery walk stations that have a photo of Guthrie paired with a quote placed at different points throughout the room. Students will rotate to each gallery walk station to analyze both the photo and the quote with their group in an effort to answer the following question:

  • Why did Woody Guthrie create and perform music?

Students should record their inferences, along with relevant evidence from the quote and/or photo, on their handout.

Divide students into four groups, each group starting at a different gallery walk station. Once students are at their assigned gallery walk station, tell them they will have two minutes at each station before rotating to the next.

Once students have completed the gallery walk and have returned to their original groups of 3-4 give students 2-3 minutes to compare their findings. Students should be encouraged to add to their notes based on this small group discussion.

When groups have concluded their conversations, ask each group to share their thinking at this point with the whole class. As students share their hypotheses about why Woody Guthrie created and performed music, ask students to note specific text evidence from the quotes and the photographs to support their responses. Slides 8-11 contain the photos and quotes from the gallery walk should you want to reference them during the whole class discussion. Please see the Music Analysis Handout - with Teacher’s Notes for additional information to help facilitate this discussion.

Next, show students this video on slide 12. As students watch the video, ask them to add information from the video to their chart that helps answer the question - Why did Woody Guthrie create and perform music? After viewing the video, ask several students to share any additional thoughts or evidence with the whole class that helps them answer the question.

After hearing from students, ask students to work with their groups to summarize their findings by completing the sentence in the bottom section of their chart - Woody Guthrie created and performed music…

Then, ask each group to share their response with the whole class. Add any missing information or clarify any misconceptions that students might have. Encourage students to modify their responses based on the whole class discussion.

Display slide 13 and summarize the discussion by noting that once Guthrie was living in California, he landed a radio show which provided Guthrie with a platform from which he developed his talent for using his music as a form of social and political commentary. He used his songs to comment, and in many cases critique, what he saw happening in American society with the hope of promoting change by informing the public about a problem or issue and appealing to their sense of justice. Therefore, to Guthrie, his songs were not purely entertainment but a tool for speaking out against social, economic, and political wrongs. Guthrie loved the possibility of America and spent the rest of his life as an artist and activist helping to create a more just America with the songs that he wrote and performed.

Explain

Now that your students know Guthrie wanted to create music to fight against the injustices he saw happening, explain to them that they are going to analyze the lyrics of various Woody Guthrie songs to determine the types of issues and causes that he felt compelled to highlight with his music.

Give each small group a different song from the curated Woody Guthrie Song List, with copies for each student in the group.

Once each group has their song, display slide 14. Tell students that before they read the lyrics they should note the title of the song and read the brief description below the title that provides some important historical context for their song analysis. Tell students to read the lyrics with their group once. Next, as they read through the lyrics a second time, they should use the Why-Lighting strategy to why-light any lyrics that address this question:

  • What political or social issue(s) is Woody Guthrie addressing in this song?

Students should highlight any words or phrases that help them to answer the question above. In the margins students should explain their reasoning for any highlighted words or phrases. While students are working with their groups, walk around to each group to answer any questions and to clarify any misconceptions. Please see the Woody Guthrie Song List - with Teacher’s Notes for why-lighting examples.

After students have finished why-lighting their lyrics, display slide 15. Bring the whole class back together and ask them to use the sentence - stem on the Music Analysis Handout to summarize their findings. Clarify to students that they should use multiple sentences to explain their evidence and reasoning.

When groups have completed their sentence stem summaries, display slide 16, and ask each group to share their analysis with the whole class. As groups share their responses, compile a class list of the major issues Guthrie highlighted with his music by typing student responses into slide 17 or writing them on the board. Additionally, ask that students record this list in the appropriate section on their Music Analysis Handout. Slide 17 includes possible answers. Conclude this discussion by summarizing the common themes and issues Guthrie addresses with his music.

Extend

While many of the themes and issues Guthrie highlighted in his music are still relevant today, giving his songs a sense of timelessness, his songs also continue to be critiqued and adapted within today’s context, perhaps none more so than, Guthrie’s most popular song, This Land Is Your Land.

Provide each student with a This Land Is Your Land Handout. Display slide 18 and ask them to listen to Guthrie’s recording of the song as they follow along with the lyrics printed on the handout. As they listen, ask students to consider the following questions and make any relevant notes on their handout:

  • What is Guthrie’s purpose for writing this song?

  • What political or social issue does he address with this song?

After listening to the song, ask students to share their responses and to the question above with the whole class. Additionally, ask students to identify the words and phrases that support their answer. Summarize your students’ thoughts at this point.

Next, display slide 19. Explain to your students that they are going to listen to a more recent recording of the same song made by Pete Seeger (one of Woody Guthrie’s friends and champions of his music) in 1976, almost ten years after Guthrie’s death. As students listen to this iteration of the song using the lyrics on the This Land is Your Land Handout to follow along, ask them to consider the following question and make any relevant notes on their handout:

  • What do you notice about Seeger’s version of the song when compared to the original lyrics?

After listening to the song, ask students to share their responses to the question about with the whole class.

Then, display slide 20 and ask students:

  • Why do you think Seeger would include these new verses in his performance of This Land Is Your Land?

Give students a few minutes to discuss this question with their small groups. When they have finished their discussion bring the whole class back together and ask each group to share their thoughts with the whole class.

Conclude the discussion by noting that this song continues to hold a significant place in our public consciousness with what seems like a simple and important message - we are all equally entitled to rights in this country, including access to and use of the land. At the same time, some have highlighted our need to consider the song within new contexts, especially as it is sung at significant events like presidential inaugurations and modern day protest events. Guthrie himself often created new iterations of his own songs to fit current circumstances so it is likely he would appreciate that this song continues to foster important dialogue about how to make the world a better place for all.

Evaluate

The Music Analysis Handout and Why-Lighted lyrics can be collected to serve as an assessments for this lesson.

If time permits, display slide 21 and consider assessing students’ understanding further, by using lyrics to one of Guthrie’s song previously analyzed by students in the class, ask students to use the Blackout Poetry Strategy to create a new blackout poem that reflects Guthrie’s social and political commentary. Once students have made their poem they should write a short response, 3-5 sentences, explaining how their poem reflects the social and political commentary Guthrie shared through his songs. Please see the Blackout Poetry Examples Handout, which includes two sample blackout poems, each with an explanation, to use as a guide.

Consider asking students to share their poems and explanations with small groups or the whole class before turning them in.

Conclude this lesson by noting that as we reflect on Woody Guthrie’s legacy, we should consider our own talents and how we can use those to fight for a society that is more just and equal, where we do a better job of taking care of one another.

Resources

Fonseca, F. (2021, January 22 ) ‘Your Land’? Some Native Americans Question Inaugural Song. PBS. Retrieved from: https://www.pbs.org/newshour/arts/your-land-some-native-americans-question-inaugural-song

Kaufman, W. (2019, August 20). The Misguided Attacks on ‘This Land Is Your Land’. The Conversation. Retrieved from: https://theconversation.com/the-misguided-attacks-on-this-land-is-your-land-121169

Kesler, S. (2021, Februrary 3). The Blind Spot In the Great American Protest Song. NPR. Retrieved from: https://www.npr.org/2021/02/03/963185860/the-blind-spot-in-the-great-american-protest-song

Logsdon, G. (n.d.). Guthrie, Woodrow Wilson (1912–1967). Oklahoma Historical Society. Retrieved from: https://www.okhistory.org/publications/enc/entry.php?entry=GU006

Obomsawin, M. (2019, June 14). This Land is Whose Land? Indian Country and the Shortcomings of Settler Protest. Smithsonian Center for Folklife & Cultural Heritage. Retrieved from: https://folklife.si.edu/magazine/this-land-is-whose-land-indian-country-settler-protest

Place, J. & Santelli, R. (2012). Woody at 100: The Woody Guthrie Centennial Collection. Smithsonian Folkways Recordings. Retrieved from: https://folkways-media.si.edu/liner_notes/smithsonian_folkways/SFW40200.pdf

The Road to Now. (2018, May 1). This episode kills fascists: The life and legacy of Woody Guthrie (promo video) [Video]. YouTube. Retrieved from: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=X7Jt_Nd96AY&t=1s

Woody Guthrie The Dustbowl Balladeer. (n.d). Crossroads from the Oklahoma Historical Society. Retrieved from: https://www.okhistory.org/crossroads/issue9/page.php?no=1

Woody Guthrie Publications, Inc. (n.d.). Woody Guthrie Lyrics. Retrieved from:https://woodyguthrie.org/Lyrics/Lyrics.htm