Summary
In this lesson, students will begin by analyzing two images depicting the conflict at the Washita River to generate hypotheses about what happened during this historical event. Next, students will read and analyze an article and complete a corresponding history frame graphic organizer. As an extension, students will evaluate and justify whether the conflict at the Washita River should be remembered as a "battle" or as a "massacre." Students will demonstrate what they have learned by creating a caption for one of the images that they viewed at the beginning of the lesson.
Essential Question(s)
Why was the conflict at the Washita River significant? Should it be remembered as a "battle" or as a "massacre"? How do our interpretations of and the way we remember and label historical events affect our understanding of the world around us?
Snapshot
Engage
Students participate in an I Notice, I Wonder image analysis.
Explore
Students read and analyze an article about the conflict at the Washita River.
Explain
Students use their article analysis to complete a History Frame.
Extend
Students evaluate whether the engagement at the Washita River should be remembered as a "battle" or as a "massacre."
Evaluate
Students create a caption for one of the images that they viewed at the beginning of the lesson to demonstrate what they have learned.
Materials
Lesson Slides (attached)
I Notice, I Wonder Chart (attached; one per student)
Student Reading (attached; one per student)
Student Reading with Teacher's Notes (attached)
History Frame (attached; one per student)
History Frame with Teacher's Notes (attached)
Battle and Massacre Signs (attached; one copy of each to hang in the classroom)
Student devices with Internet access (optional)
Engage
Use the attached Lesson Slides to guide the lesson. Display slide 2 and begin by organizing students into groups of four. Students will engage in a modified Think, Pair, Share activity. For this activity, the "Think" portion will involve completing an I Notice, I Wonder chart.
Give each student a copy of the attached I Notice, I Wonder chart. Tell students that they will view two different images of the same historical event and record at least one thing they "notice" (something that they see in the images) and at least one thing they "wonder" (questions they have based on what they see in the images) about each image.
Display slide 3 to reveal the first image, The Seventh U.S. Cavalry Charging Into Black Kettle's Village at Daylight. Give students a few minutes to record their responses individually in the I Notice, I Wonder chart.
Display slide 4 to reveal the second image, The 1868 Battle of the Washita. Again, give students a few minutes to record their responses individually in the I Notice, I Wonder Chart.
Return to the first image on slide 3. Invite students to "pair" with one or two other students to discuss the things that they noticed and wondered about the image. Students should add to their I Notice, I Wonder charts based on their conversations with their peers. Once students have had a few minutes to discuss, ask student groups to choose one or two responses to share out with the whole class. When you feel that enough has been said about the first image, move to slide 4 to display the second image, and repeat the pair-and-share process.
Display slide 5. Ask students to return to their groups and discuss the question on the slide: What do you think is happening in these images? Using your existing knowledge to justify your response, why do you think that? Explain to students that their answer does not have to be correct, but it should be a well-reasoned hypothesis based on their prior knowledge and what they observed in the images. Invite groups to share out their hypotheses. Conclude the discussion by noting that the images depict a conflict between the U.S. Army and the Cheyenne that took place at the Washita River in Indian Territory (now Oklahoma) in the winter of 1868.
Display slide 6 and explain to students that throughout the lesson, they will be exploring the following essential questions: Why is the conflict at the Washita River significant? Should the conflict at the Washita River be remembered as a "battle" or as a "massacre?" How do our interpretations of and the way we remember and label historical events impact our understanding of the world around us? Additionally, display slide 7 to review the learning objectives for this lesson.
Explore
Display slide 8. To explore the essential questions and learning objectives, explain to students that they will begin by working with groups of four to read and analyze an article about the conflict at the Washita River. Students will be using a modified version of the POMS (Point of Most Significance) strategy to help with their analysis of the text. After reading each section, students will work with their group to identify a point of most significance. Thus, by the end of the reading, they will have developed a total of four POMS statements to summarize the most significant information from each section of the text.
Distribute copies of the attached Student Reading handout. Ask students to read through section 1 (the first three paragraphs) with their groups. Give groups approximately five minutes to discuss what they think the POMS is for that section, but tell them not to write anything down yet—instead, have them prepare to share their ideas with the class. Call on several groups to share their ideas. Once you have heard from the groups, synthesize the various contributions to craft the first POMS as a class. Have students write down the statement that you craft for POMS 1.
Allow groups time to work through the remaining three sections of the article, instructing them to stop at the end of each section to document a POMS.
When groups have wrapped up their reading, assign each group one of the POMS (2–4) to share with the whole class. As groups share their responses, clarify any missing or inaccurate information, and encourage students to modify their responses based on the whole-class discussion.
Explain
Display slide 9 and pass out a copy of the attached History Frame to each student. Still working with their groups, students should use the information from the article and the POMS activity to respond to the prompts in the History Frame graphic organizer.
Once groups have completed the history frame, assign each group a different part of the graphic organizer to share out. You might consider grouping together the Participants/Key Players, When, and Where sections, asking one group to share all three, as those are the "easy" sections. You might also ask several groups to share one or two items from the Causes/Conflicts section or from the Effects/Resolution section, as there should be more than one answer in those sections. The goal is to generate a class discussion where information that belongs in the graphic organizer is shared, confirmed, synthesized, and modified if needed.
Extend
Display slide 10. Remind students that, as the article mentioned, there has been controversy surrounding the way the Washita River conflict is remembered and memorialized. This engagement was identified in official U.S. Army reports as the Battle of the Washita, and, thus, it is popularly referred to as such. However, some have argued that what took place during this conflict should not be labeled as a battle but rather a massacre. Invite students to consider how our interpretations of and the way we remember historical events impact our understanding of the world around us, specifically the power of word choice and how language affects that understanding.
In reference to the importance of word choice when memorializing historical events, ask students how they would define the words "battle" and "massacre." What is the difference? Once you have heard from multiple students, display slide 11, which shows the dictionary definitions for both words. Ask students to keep those definitions in mind as they participate in the next activity.
Explain to students that they are going to participate in a modified Four Corners activity. The modification is that, rather than there being four options, there will be only two—battle and massacre. Post the attached Battle and Massacre Signs on opposite sides of the room. Ask students, given what they have learned about the conflict at the Washita River, if they feel the event should be remembered as a battle or as a massacre. As students decide, they should move to the side of the room with the sign representing their choice. Once they have chosen a side, ask students to organize themselves into groups of two or three.
Give groups 5-10 minutes to discuss why they think the event should be called a "battle" or a "massacre." Students should consider the evidence that they can use to support their choice. After time is up, give each group the opportunity to share their reasoning with the whole class.
Display slide 12. To conclude the discussion, invite students to consider the following essential question with their groups: How do our interpretations of and the way we remember and label historical events affect our understanding of the world around us? After allowing approximately five minutes for discussion, call on multiple groups to share their responses with the whole class.
Evaluate
Display slide 13. Invite students to choose one of the two images from the beginning of the lesson (which are also repeated on slides 14 and 15). Using the Caption This strategy, ask students to create a caption showcasing what they have learned about the conflict at the Washita River. Captions should be between 1-3 sentences, and students should incorporate what they have learned about the conflict to explain what is happening in the image.
Resources
Harper’s Weekly. (1868, December 19). The Seventh U.S. Cavalry charging into Black Kettle’s village at daylight, Nov. 27, 1868 [Image]. Library of Congress. https://www.loc.gov/item/96521161/
K20 Center. (n.d.). Caption This. Strategies. https://learn.k20center.ou.edu/strategy/82
K20 Center. (n.d.). Claim, Evidence, Reasoning (CER). Strategies. https://learn.k20center.ou.edu/strategy/156
K20 Center. (n.d.). Four Corners. Strategies. https://learn.k20center.ou.edu/strategy/138
K20 Center. (n.d.). Google Classroom. Tech Tools. https://learn.k20center.ou.edu/tech-tool/628
K20 Center. (n.d.). I Notice, I Wonder. Strategies. https://learn.k20center.ou.edu/strategy/180
K20 Center. (n.d.). Padlet. Tech Tools. https://learn.k20center.ou.edu/tech-tool/1077
K20 Center. (n.d.). POMS: Point of Most Significance. Strategies. https://learn.k20center.ou.edu/strategy/101
K20 Center. (n.d.). Think-Pair-Share. Strategies. https://learn.k20center.ou.edu/strategy/139
Lang, S. (2003). The 1868 battle of the Washita [Image]. National Park Service. https://www.nps.gov/waba/learn/historyculture/index.htm.